CareNav 360 Insights
CQC and Adult Social CareLeadership and RetentionOfsted and Children's Residential Care

Difficult Staff Cultures in Care Homes: How to Manage Them and Build Stronger Teams

A difficult staff culture can affect morale, retention and the quality of care residents receive. Discover how care home managers can identify unhealthy team dynamics, address challenging behaviours and build a positive, accountable and supportive workplace.

By CareNav 360 · Published · Updated

Staff Culture

A care home can have the right policies, procedures and staffing structure on paper, but still struggle with something much harder to manage: its workplace culture.

For Registered Managers, Deputy Managers and senior leaders, dealing with difficult staff cultures can be one of the most challenging aspects of running a care service.

Cliques, negativity, poor communication, resistance to change and a lack of accountability can gradually become embedded within a team. Left unaddressed, these behaviours can affect staff morale, increase turnover, undermine leadership and, most importantly, impact the experience and quality of care received by residents.

Creating a positive workplace culture is not simply about having a happy workforce. It is about establishing an environment where staff understand expectations, treat one another with respect, take responsibility for their actions and remain focused on delivering safe, compassionate and person-centred care.

So, how should care home managers approach difficult staff cultures?

  1. Recognise the Signs of an Unhealthy Staff Culture

One of the biggest mistakes managers can make is allowing negative behaviours to become accepted as part of everyday working life.

An unhealthy culture does not necessarily develop overnight. It can emerge gradually through poor leadership, unresolved disagreements, inconsistent management decisions or a small number of individuals influencing the wider team.

Some common warning signs include:

  • Staff forming cliques and excluding colleagues.
  • Negative conversations, gossip and persistent criticism.
  • Experienced employees resisting new management or changes to working practices.
  • Staff questioning management decisions in an unconstructive or undermining way.
  • Poor communication between shifts and departments.
  • A reluctance to support colleagues during busy periods.
  • Repeated complaints about fairness, workload or management decisions.
  • Staff becoming reluctant to raise concerns or challenge poor practice.
  • High staff turnover or repeated sickness absence.

Managers should look beyond individual incidents and consider whether there is an underlying pattern.

For example, if several employees independently raise concerns about communication, favouritism or inconsistent expectations, this may indicate a wider cultural problem rather than an isolated disagreement.

Understanding the difference is essential before deciding how to respond.

  1. Do Not Allow Cliques to Control the Working Environment

Cliques can be particularly damaging in care home settings.

They often develop when a group of established employees become comfortable working together and begin to influence how the wider team operates.

This can create an environment where new employees feel excluded, certain staff members believe they have greater influence than others, and management decisions are challenged or ignored.

In some cases, employees may begin to follow the expectations of an informal group rather than the standards established by the organisation.

Managers should address this early.

Practical steps include:

  • Establishing clear expectations around professional behaviour.
  • Ensuring new employees receive proper induction and support.
  • Encouraging staff to work across different teams and shifts.
  • Challenging exclusion, gossip and inappropriate behaviour.
  • Applying policies and procedures consistently.
  • Making it clear that no individual or group operates outside organisational expectations.

It is important not to assume that every disagreement or friendship group represents a problem. The concern arises when relationships begin to affect teamwork, fairness, communication or the delivery of care.

Managers must create an environment where everyone feels included and understands that professional standards apply equally.

  1. Be Visible, Consistent and Confident in Your Leadership

Staff cultures are heavily influenced by leadership behaviour.

A manager who avoids difficult conversations, frequently changes decisions or applies rules inconsistently can unintentionally contribute to an unstable working environment.

Equally, a manager who relies entirely on authority without listening to employees may create resentment and further resistance.

Effective leadership requires a balance of approachability, consistency and accountability.

Managers should:

  • Be visible within the service and engage with staff regularly.
  • Communicate expectations clearly.
  • Follow through on decisions and agreed actions.
  • Apply policies fairly and consistently.
  • Recognise positive behaviour and good performance.
  • Address inappropriate conduct promptly.
  • Demonstrate the professional standards expected from the wider team.

Staff need to understand that management decisions are fair, considered and based on the needs of the service.

Consistency is particularly important. If one employee is challenged for inappropriate behaviour while another is allowed to continue without consequence, confidence in leadership will quickly deteriorate.

  1. Address Poor Behaviour Rather Than Ignoring It

Avoiding difficult conversations rarely makes workplace problems disappear.

In fact, when inappropriate behaviour goes unchallenged, employees may begin to believe that it is acceptable.

Managers should address concerns promptly, professionally and fairly.

This starts with understanding what has happened rather than immediately making assumptions.

A sensible approach is to:

Establish the facts

Speak to the individuals involved, review relevant information and identify whether there is a repeated pattern of behaviour.

Understand the underlying issue

Consider whether the behaviour relates to a disagreement, lack of training, unclear expectations, workload pressures or a more serious conduct concern.

Explain the expected standards

Make clear what needs to change and why the behaviour is unacceptable.

Agree actions

Set out specific expectations, timescales and any support required.

Monitor progress

Follow up to establish whether the situation has improved and whether further action is necessary.

Where concerns involve bullying, harassment, discrimination, safeguarding, misconduct or other serious allegations, managers must follow the appropriate organisational procedures rather than treating the matter as an informal disagreement.

Fairness is essential. Staff should have an opportunity to respond to concerns, and decisions should be based on evidence.

  1. Improve Communication Between Staff and Management

Poor communication is one of the most common contributors to workplace frustration.

In a care home, staff work different shifts, have different responsibilities and often operate under considerable pressure.

Without effective communication, misunderstandings can develop quickly.

Information may not be passed between shifts, changes to residents' needs may not be communicated effectively, and employees may feel that management decisions are being made without their involvement.

Managers can improve communication by introducing or strengthening:

  • Regular staff meetings.
  • Effective shift handovers.
  • Structured one-to-one supervision.
  • Clear communication channels.
  • Opportunities for staff to raise suggestions and concerns.
  • Consistent updates about operational changes.

Communication should be a two-way process.

Managers should not simply tell staff what is happening. They should also listen, consider feedback and explain the reasoning behind decisions where appropriate.

Staff are more likely to support changes when they understand why they are necessary and feel that their views have been considered.

  1. Use Supervision to Understand What Is Happening Within the Team

Supervision should be more than a routine administrative exercise.

It provides managers with an opportunity to understand how employees are feeling, identify development needs, discuss concerns and reinforce professional expectations.

Regular, meaningful supervision can help identify problems before they become more serious.

Useful discussion areas include:

  • How the employee feels about their role.
  • Relationships with colleagues.
  • Workload and working pressures.
  • Training and development needs.
  • Confidence and competence.
  • Any concerns about management or communication.
  • Professional conduct and performance expectations.

Supervision should be supportive, but it must also include accountability.

Where an employee's behaviour or performance needs to improve, this should be discussed openly and documented appropriately.

Managers should also consider whether they need to improve their own approach or provide additional support to help employees succeed.

  1. Deal With Resistance to Change

Care homes regularly need to adapt.

Changes may involve new management, revised procedures, improvements to documentation, changes to staffing arrangements or developments in the way care is delivered.

However, not every employee will welcome change.

Long-serving members of staff may be particularly comfortable with established routines and may question new approaches.

Managers should recognise that resistance can sometimes come from uncertainty, a lack of understanding or previous negative experiences.

However, experience and length of service should never give an employee the authority to disregard reasonable management instructions or organisational policies.

A structured approach can help:

  1. Explain what is changing.
  2. Communicate why the change is necessary.
  3. Involve staff where appropriate.
  4. Provide training and support.
  5. Set clear expectations.
  6. Monitor implementation.
  7. Address continued resistance fairly.

Change should be managed with communication and support, but managers must remain confident in their responsibilities.

  1. Keep Residents at the Centre of Every Decision

When staff relationships become difficult, it is easy for management attention to become focused entirely on internal disagreements.

However, the primary purpose of a care home is to provide safe, effective and compassionate care.

Managers must continually consider whether workplace culture is affecting residents.

For example:

  • Are staff disagreements affecting communication about residents?
  • Are handovers being completed properly?
  • Are employees supporting one another to meet residents' needs?
  • Are negative attitudes influencing the way residents are treated?
  • Are safeguarding concerns being raised and acted upon?
  • Are residents experiencing inconsistent care because of poor teamwork?

An unhealthy staff culture can become a wider quality-of-care concern if it affects professional standards, safeguarding or residents' dignity and wellbeing.

Managers must never allow internal staff disputes to distract from their responsibility to protect residents.

Any indication of abuse, neglect, unsafe practice or a closed culture must be addressed through the appropriate safeguarding and regulatory procedures.

  1. Know When Informal Management Is No Longer Enough

Not every workplace issue can be resolved through a conversation or team meeting.

Some situations require a more formal management response.

Examples include:

  • Repeated bullying or harassment.
  • Serious breaches of professional conduct.
  • Persistent failure to follow care procedures.
  • Discrimination or victimisation.
  • Deliberate refusal to follow reasonable instructions.
  • Repeated poor performance despite support.
  • Conduct that places residents or colleagues at risk.

Managers should follow the organisation's disciplinary, grievance, safeguarding and whistleblowing procedures as appropriate.

It is equally important to ensure employees feel safe raising concerns.

A culture where staff are afraid to speak up can allow poor practice to continue unchecked.

Managers should encourage openness, protect confidentiality as far as possible and ensure concerns are investigated fairly.

Where a concern relates to immediate resident safety or potential abuse, it must be escalated without delay.

  1. Rebuild the Culture Through Clear Expectations and Positive Leadership

Changing an established workplace culture takes time.

A new manager cannot realistically expect every issue to disappear within a few weeks. However, they can begin establishing a clear direction from the outset.

A practical starting point is to introduce a set of shared expectations covering:

Respect: Everyone is treated professionally, regardless of role, experience or length of service.

Accountability: Employees take responsibility for their actions and understand the standards expected of them.

Communication: Information is shared appropriately and concerns are raised constructively.

Teamwork: Staff support one another and work towards shared objectives.

Compassion: Residents and colleagues are treated with dignity, patience and understanding.

Continuous improvement: Feedback is welcomed, mistakes are used as learning opportunities and poor practice is challenged.

These expectations must be demonstrated through everyday leadership rather than simply displayed on a noticeboard.

Managers should recognise good practice, celebrate improvements and ensure that employees who demonstrate positive behaviours feel valued.

  1. A Practical 30-Day Approach for Care Home Managers

For managers inheriting a difficult team culture, a structured first month can help establish priorities.

Week 1 – Understand the Culture

Spend time observing the service, speaking with employees and understanding existing working relationships.

Review staff feedback, turnover, sickness patterns, complaints, incidents and any outstanding management concerns.

Avoid making assumptions before understanding the situation.

Week 2 – Establish Expectations

Communicate the standards expected across the service.

Address any immediate concerns, clarify management responsibilities and ensure employees understand the importance of teamwork and professional conduct.

Week 3 – Address Individual and Team Issues

Arrange appropriate supervision meetings, address recurring concerns and identify any training or development needs.

Where formal action is necessary, follow the relevant procedures.

Week 4 – Review and Build Momentum

Assess what has improved, identify outstanding issues and agree further actions.

Recognise positive contributions and continue reinforcing the behaviours expected from the team.

The process does not end after 30 days. Building a sustainable workplace culture requires consistent leadership and ongoing attention.

Final Thoughts: Difficult Cultures Require Strong Leadership

Managing a difficult staff culture is one of the most demanding responsibilities within a care home.

It requires patience, confidence, consistency and a willingness to address problems that others may have previously avoided.

However, managers should remember that a difficult culture is not always caused by a handful of challenging employees. It can also reflect weaknesses in communication, management, organisational processes and leadership.

The most effective approach is to understand the underlying issues, establish clear expectations, support employees appropriately and address unacceptable behaviour fairly.

Ultimately, a positive care home culture is built when staff feel respected, supported and accountable, and when everyone understands that residents' wellbeing must remain at the centre of the service.

At CareNav 360, we recognise the importance of strong leadership in building stable, effective care teams.

Through our permanent and fixed-term recruitment and interim management services, we support care providers in identifying experienced professionals who can help strengthen their services and lead teams with confidence.

If your care service is experiencing management challenges or you are looking to strengthen your leadership team, contact CareNav 360 to discuss how we may be able to help.

CareNav 360 Ltd

Recruitment & Interim Management Built on Real Experience.

contact@carenav360.co.uk
www.carenav360.co.uk

LET’S TALK ABOUT YOUR NEXT APPOINTMENT

Recruitment that understands care.

From frontline care staff to Registered Managers and senior operational leaders, tell us what your organisation needs.

Discuss Your Recruitment Requirements

contact@carenav360.co.uk · carenav360.co.uk